This week I thought I would address things slightly differently; partly because not much new is happening in my TV world.
As we all know, one of my current favourite shows, The Biggest Loser, has an American counterpart which I often compare to our version as being more dynamic, more fast-paced, and just generally more exciting. This week saw the start of the American version of Tool Academy, another of my current guilty pleasures. Obviously because of this I decided to tune in and compare to our version. Tellingly, the series currently running is Tool Academy 3, meaning, as with The Biggest Loser, that if U.S TV production companies did not come up with these programmes we would never get anything slightly comparable here! However, we often water down the ideas, meaning we end up with a slightly vapid version of the original.
Take The Biggest Loser for example…our version was first broadcast on Living (channel) for two series several years ago, then disappeared from the air for several years before being resurrected by ITV first as a daytime show, and currently in a prime time position. It’s just not quite the same as the original U.S show though. The same format is followed, currently pairs of family/friends/strangers start the show, then halfway through the remaining contestants are split into two teams. However, as everything is bigger and (often) better in the U.S there are always a lot more teams (this season they started with 16 couples compared to our starting line up of 8), and a lot more twists as the show proceeds…this season on BL USA two teams were ‘sent home’ on day one, but unknown to the others they return after 30 days, with the couple who lose the most weight returning to the show. Because the series run is longer it makes it possible to pull stunts like this; our show runs for eight weeks and to bring someone back halfway through this time would not really be feasible. Temptations are bigger, prizes are bigger, and generally the contestants are bigger, with several starting at around half a ton this time around! Also, the trainers are more willing to ‘break’ their contestants with hard work and humiliation. Don’t get me wrong, I love our version of the show, but when another, better version of it is also showing (on a different channel) it takes a little of the magic away!
It really should have been obvious to me that there would have been an American version of Tool Academy, especially considering that the insult ‘tool’ is an American put-down. And this week it appeared. Following the precedent this too is a more humiliating version of our show, on a slightly grander scale and with more couples. I was pleasantly surprised to note that the tools in this version were not all men, as in our show, but a couple of women were included as the bad person which was refreshing. Also the humiliation piled upon the patient, doting partner came thick and fast, with virtually every tool admitting to infidelities in pre-recorded interviews shown in front of the whole group as part of the first group therapy session, resulting in many partners walking out-stupidly they decided to come back and continue. Our poor guys at least had a couple of weeks before the videos of them kissing girls in strip club toilets were shown to the group, resulting in the obvious disgust of their other halves! Getting it all out with extra drama is what the Americans do best, and I like it this way, although I also stand by our slightly mediocre versions!
Hells Kitchen USA is a prime example of a U.S network taking one of our concepts and making it work; whilst HK only ran for a couple of series over here with Gordan Ramsey at the helm, it is going strong in the U.S . Keeping the concept consistent has ensured that you know exactly what you are getting, and using real people is definitely better than the introduction of celebrities to our version. Add Gordan to the mix and you can be sure off passion and arrogance in the kitchen; further to this add fourteen chefs of varying experience (generally only a couple of them are actually any good) who all think they will win it and the kitchen ends up full of egotistical Americans who never fail to annoy, but that is the whole enjoyment of watching.
It proves, I think, that during the journey from one continent to another something gets lost, even when the same format is being followed. However, when travelling in the opposite direction that doesn’t always happen; in fact sometimes our show gets improved!
Tomorrow sees the introduction of a new country to the mix (Australia already has Masterchef and Biggest Loser – the latter definitely more in line with the U.S than us) as Masterchef New Zealand starts on Watch. The adverts for this suggest it will follow the Australian format, as do the ads for our version of the show, which starts on February 16th. It will be interesting to see if we ruin this concept, as I actually prefer the way they did it to our old style show…we’ll just have to wait and see. You know that I’ll have something to say about it though!
Until next time…
XOXOXO